| artist | title | hits (month) | hits (total) | submitted by |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | A Baby For Pree | 561 | 625 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | A Love That Can’t Be Sold | 123 | 138 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | April 8th | 122 | 138 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | Communist Daughter | 116 | 130 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | Engine | 138 | 154 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | Engine (Live) | 126 | 142 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | Everything Is | 142 | 157 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | Gardenhead/ Leave Me Alone | 158 | 173 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | Ghost | 124 | 142 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | Holland, 1945 | 140 | 154 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | I Love How You Love Me | 120 | 136 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | In The Aeroplane Over The Sea | 118 | 134 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | Naomi | 164 | 178 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | Oh Comely | 148 | 162 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | Sinking Ship | 146 | 163 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | Snow Song | 120 | 137 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | Someone Is Waiting | 154 | 170 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | Song Against Sex | 120 | 134 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | The King Of Carrot Flowers Part One | 130 | 145 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | The King Of Carrot Flowers Parts Two & Three | 130 | 147 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | Three Peaches | 137 | 151 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | Two-Headed Boy Part 2 | 131 | 148 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | Two-Headed Boy Pt. 1 | 124 | 140 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | Where You’ll Find Me Now | 116 | 134 | Annie |
| Neutral Milk Hotel | You’ve Passed | 117 | 137 | Annie |
25 Results
All songs by 'Neutral Milk Hotel'
